Timeless vs. Trendy: Which Exterior Colors Add the Most Value to Your Home?
Choosing the perfect exterior paint color for your home is a big and challenging decision. Not only does the color affect curb appeal, but it can also impact resale value of your home. In Fairfield County and Westchester County, where homes range from historic estates to modern luxury properties, homeowners often ask: Should I go for a trendy look that’s popular now or be safe with a timeless shade that does not go out of style?
At Regal Line Painting, we’ve painted thousands of homes, and we have a very good idea of the right color that can make all the difference. In this guide, we will break down the pros and cons of timeless and trendy exterior colors, highlight some of the most popular choices for 2025, and help you decide which is best for your home.
Timeless Exterior Colors: A Safe and Elegant Choice
Timeless colors are classic, sophisticated, and never seem to go out of style. They are often neutral or muted tones that blend well with any architectural style and design, they are always a safe investment for homeowners.
Top Timeless Exterior Colors
White & Off-White – Think classic white homes with black shutters or soft off-whites like Benjamin Moore’s “White Dove” or Sherwin-Williams’ “Alabaster.” These shades exude elegance and work beautifully on both traditional and modern homes.
Greige (Gray + Beige) – A mix of gray and beige, colors like Sherwin-Williams’ “Repose Gray” or Benjamin Moore’s “Revere Pewter” are popular choices for high-end homes in Greenwich, New Canaan, Darien, Scarsdale and all the beautiful homes in Fairfield County and Westchester County.
Soft Gray & Charcoal – Always timeless and sophisticated, grays like “Classic Gray” or deep charcoals like “Iron Mountain” (Benjamin Moore) add a clean and modern touch.
Navy Blue – A deep navy like “Hale Navy” by Benjamin Moore pairs beautifully with white trim and adds a luxurious feel to homes in Fairfield County and Westhester County.
Earthy Greens & Warm Taupes – Shades like “Sage Green Light” or “Edgecomb Gray” blend beautifuylly with nature and work well for traditional homes as well.
Benefits of Timeless Colors
High Resale Value – Neutral colors appeal to the majority of buyers and rarely go out of style.
Blends Well with Any Style – Whether you own a historic colonial in Westport or a modern farmhouse in Rye, timeless colors work asll the time.
Easier Maintenance – Classic tones show less dirt and wear over time. Besides the fact that it ends up being more cost effective on the long run.
When to Choose a Timeless Color
- If you plan to sell your home in the next few years, neutral colors will definitelly attract more buyers.
- If you want a sophisticated and classic look that stands the test of time.
- If your home has architectural details that should shine without a bold color overshadowing them.
Trendy Exterior Colors: Modern and Bold Choices for 2025
Warm Terracotta & Clay Tones – Earthy reds and burnt oranges are gaining popularity lately, especially for Mediterranean and modern homes in Westchester County.
Moody Dark Greens – Shades like Benjamin Moore’s “Essex Green” or Sherwin-Williams’ “Ripe Olive” add a dramatic and contemporary feel.
Charcoal Black & Deep Espresso – Darker homes are trending, with colors like “Tricorn Black” (Sherwin-Williams) making a bold statement and stands out.
Dusty Blue & Teal – Softer blues like “Slate Blue” or bolder teal shades create a coastal-chic vibe, perfect for waterfront properties in Fairfield County and westchester County.
Golden Yellow & Mustard Hues – While risky, these colors can give a home a vibrant and unique personality when paired with the right trim and details.
Benefits of Trendy Colors
Makes a Bold Statement – If you want your home to stand out, trendy colors help you create a unique look. Showcases Your Style and Personality. Homeowners who love modern aesthetics or bold designs can express their style.
Can Be a Neighborhood Trendsetter – Some trendy colors can increase property value if they match the evolving style of your area when done right.
When to Choose a Trendy Color
- If you love bold and modern design and want your home to stand out in your area.
- If you don’t mind repainting in 5-7 years as trends shifts constantly.
- If your home is a contemporary or modern build that benefits from bold colors.
Timeless vs. Trendy: Which Adds More Value to Your Home?
Timeless Colors = Higher Resale Value & Broader Appeal
- Most real estate experts recommend neutral and timeless colors because they appeal to a wider range of buyers and are less personal.
- If you live in a high-end area like Greenwich or Scarsdale, a neutral exterior can definitely increase your home’s marketability.
- Timeless colors tend to stay in style longer, reducing the need for frequent repaints.
Trendy Colors = High Impact But Potentially Short-Lived
- A trendy color can increase curb appeal immediately, making your home feel modern and fresh.
- However, trends shift, and what’s “in” today might be completely outdated in a few years.
- If you plan to sell within 3-5 years, a bold colorcould limit potential buyers.
The Best Strategy: A Balance of Both
One way to enjoy both timeless and trendy colors is to keep the the siding of your home in a classic shade and use a trendy color on accents like:
- Front doors (bold colors like teal, red, or mustard)
- Shutters (deep greens or blues)
- Trim or garage doors (soft contrasting hues)
This smart approach allows you to refresh your home’s look with small updates over time while keeping the main color safe and sophisticated. It’s also easier to change it in a faster and affordable way.
In Conclusion
Whether you choose timeless or trendy, your home’s exterior color is a reflection of your style, neighborhood, and your future plans.
- If you want maximum resale value, stick with classic colors like whites, grays, navy blues, and earth tones.
- If you love a bold, modern look, deep greens, moody blues, or black exteriors are on trend for 2025.
- A combination of neutral main colors with trendy accent tones can offer the best of both worlds.
At Regal Line Painting, we specialize in helping Fairfield and Westchester County homeowners choose the perfect color to enhance curb appeal and add value to their homes. Whether you’re looking for a classic, elegant look or a bold, modern refresh, our team of experts is here to bring your vision to life.
Thinking about updating your home’s exterior this Spring?
Call Regal Line Painting today for a free consultation!
